Can you negotiate prices on Mercari Japan through a proxy?
Sometimes, but not freely. Inside Japan, buyers ask Mercari sellers for a lower price all the time, either with Mercari’s own price-request feature or in the comments. Through a proxy, you can only negotiate if your service offers it as a service, and those that do set their own limits. FROM JAPAN, for example, has a written process for Mercari price negotiation; with other services, check before you assume.
How price negotiation works on Mercari Japan
Asking for a discount is called 値下げ交渉 (price negotiation), and it is part of everyday Mercari culture. There are two ways buyers in Japan do it:
- The price-request button, 値下げ依頼 (price reduction request). A buyer enters the price they would pay, and the seller chooses 売る (sell) or 売らない (don’t sell). If the seller accepts, they change the listing price and the buyer has 24 hours to buy. Mercari’s help page says an accepted request is not a promise to buy, and other people can still buy the item at the new price first. The button doesn’t appear on items priced at 300 JPY or less, Mercari Shops items, sold-out items or auctions (Mercari help centre, checked November 8, 2026).
- Comments on the listing. Buyers also write a polite question in the public comments, and some sellers then lower the price or mark the item 専用 (reserved) for that buyer.
Many sellers say up front how they feel about it. Phrases such as 値下げ不可 (no price reductions) or 値下げ交渉不可 (no negotiation) in a description mean a request will be ignored. Others write that they will consider offers, or set a slightly higher price expecting to be asked.
Why most proxies don’t haggle for you
A proxy buys with its own Japanese account. Negotiation means writing to the seller, waiting, and then buying quickly once the seller agrees, all while the item stays on sale to everyone else. That is staff time for a small saving, and the item may be gone before it finishes. Most services keep things simple: you pay the listed price, they buy at once. Many also ask customers not to contact sellers directly, because the proxy is the account holder on Mercari.
FROM JAPAN’s Mercari negotiation
FROM JAPAN publishes a process for this (FROM JAPAN help page, checked November 8, 2026). In short:
- It applies to Mercari items listed at 10,000 JPY or more.
- You can ask for up to 10% off the listed price.
- You enter your target price and what to do if it fails in the Comments field, then add the item to your cart and pay the first payment (Charge 1). If you give no price, staff ask for 10% off.
- If the seller agrees, staff buy at the lower price and refund the difference to your original payment method.
- If the seller says no, staff ask whether you want to buy at the listed price or cancel. They also follow up if the seller hasn’t replied within three days.
If you pay without writing a negotiation request, the item is bought at the listed price straight away. The page also warns that the item can sell to someone else while the negotiation is going on.
Buyee and other services
We did not find a Mercari price-negotiation option described on Buyee’s own help pages, so we can’t say whether Buyee will send an offer for you. Check its help centre or ask its support before you plan around a discount. The same goes for every other proxy: some take a negotiation request as a note on the order, some decline it outright, and the rules change. A guide to asking a seller a question through a proxy covers the related case of asking about condition or bundles.
Realistic expectations
| Situation | Chance a request helps |
|---|---|
| Popular item, fair price, listed minutes ago | Low. Someone else will likely buy it before the seller even replies. |
| Item listed for weeks, many likes | Better. The seller may already be thinking of lowering it. |
| Description says 値下げ不可 | Very low, and asking can annoy the seller. |
| Several items from one seller | Sometimes. Bundle requests, まとめ買い (buying several together), are a common reason to ask. |
A small discount also has to beat the extra costs. Your proxy’s service fee and international shipping usually stay the same whatever the item price, so 10% off a 10,000 JPY item saves less of your total than it looks. Before asking, compare the price with sold listings; using sold listings to judge a fair price explains how.
A different way to pay less
Prices on Mercari vary a lot from one listing to the next. Rather than haggling over one item, many buyers wait for a listing that is already priced well and order it quickly. A saved search with a sensible price range in FleaHunter alerts you when a match appears, and the app’s Check market screen shows what similar items actually sold for.